Defendant Claiming God Ordered Killing of Lover Never Told Cops That - gaycitynews.com | gaycitynews.com Defendant Claiming God Ordered Killing of Lover Never Told Cops That - gaycitynews.com | gaycitynews.com

Defendant Claiming God Ordered Killing of Lover Never Told Cops That

Renato Seabra now claims he acted as a “conduit for God” when he castrated and killed Carlos Castro.

BY DUNCAN OSBORNE | While the accused killer of Carlos Castro asserted in court filings that “he was acting as a conduit for God” when he killed the 65-year-old Portuguese TV personality and gay activist in a Manhattan hotel last year, he did not tell police that when he gave them a statement roughly 36 hours after the homicide.

“Did he say who told him to commit this crime?” David Touger, the attorney for Renato Seabra, asked Richard Tirelli, a homicide detective, during a September 14 court hearing. Tirelli said “No.”

Castro and Seabra, who turned 23 on September 10, had been involved in an “intimate relationship” since October 2010, Seabra told police, when they traveled to New York City in January of 2011.

They argued and Seabra launched an hour-long attack on Castro. He first strangled Castro, then stabbed him in the face and groin with a corkscrew. After removing Castro’s testicles with the corkscrew, he hit Castro’s head with a computer monitor and “stomped on Carlos’ face while wearing shoes,” according to a paraphrased version of the statement Seabra gave police that was in court filings.

When the January 7 attack was finished, Seabra showered and dressed in a suit. He wandered around Midtown Manhattan, then a cab driver saw the wounds Seabra had made on his wrists and drove him to St. Luke’s Roosevelt Hospital.

Police tried to interview Seabra there, but hospital staff said he was “heavily sedated” and could not speak to them, Tirelli testified. He was transferred to Bellevue Hospital, and police interviewed him there on January 8.

Seabra told police he was “struggling with his homosexuality and his demons” and that “he had second-guessed his sexuality,” said Tirelli, who was reading Seabra’s statement in court. Seabra told Tirelli he became enraged because he “could not control the virus of homosexuality that was spreading throughout the world,” the detective said.

“He made it pretty clear to you that he thought he had made the world a better place by committing these acts, correct?” Touger asked. Tirelli said, “Yes.”

Seabra did not tell police that he was acting on instructions from God. A psychiatrist, Dr. Robert Harris, and Mark H. Goldenthal, a psychologist, both of whom were hired by the defense, diagnosed him with “Bipolar I Disorder, Single Manic Episode, Severe with Psychotic features,” according to a 2011 court filing.

In that same court filing, Touger wrote, “Mr. Seabra developed a manic episode and became fulminantly psychotic. He acted on his delusional ideas when he attacked and killed Mr. Castro. He did not appreciate the wrongfulness of his actions, as he was acting as a conduit for God.”

Touger will use a mental disease or defect defense –– an insanity defense as it is commonly known –– that asserts that Seabra could not tell right from wrong when he killed Castro so he cannot be held criminally liable. If a jury agrees, Seabra will be institutionalized until doctors decide he is no longer a threat.

Seabra faces one second-degree murder count that alleges he intended to kill Castro. The maximum penalty for second-degree murder is 25-years-to-life.

Juries generally do not like insanity defenses, and they can react badly to defendants who appear to have embellished their stories after the fact. When gay sex is involved in a crime, jurors have at times seen that as a reasonable explanation for behavior they might otherwise deem to be criminal.

Touger also questioned Michael De Almeida, the detective who was the interpreter for the Seabra interview, about any orders from the divine.

“He never mentioned that God instructed him to do this?” Touger asked. De Almeida said, “No, he did not.”

The hearing was held to determine if the statement was taken in accordance with Seabra’s rights. Michael J. Obus, the judge in the case, ruled that Seabra had waived his rights and gave the statement voluntarily so prosecutors can use it at trial.

“I’m satisfied that whatever Mr. Seabra’s condition was the day before… at that time, Mr. Seabra certainly was capable of being interviewed,” Obus said at the close of the hearing.

A doctor at Bellevue told police that Seabra was “coherent, not sedated,” Tirelli testified. De Almeida said Seabra was “calm, cooperative, very comfortable” during the interview.

At the close of the interview, crime scene detectives arrived at the hospital and asked Seabra to voluntarily give them a DNA sample. He refused.

Jury selection will begin on September 19.

Share This Post

12 Responses to Defendant Claiming God Ordered Killing of Lover Never Told Cops That

  1. ludwig September 20, 2012 at 6:50 pm

    He may claim anything he wishes in court but it all boils down can he prove God concretely told him to do it.?? God needs to be on the witness stand and at least convicted of being an accessory to murder. This man' claim is nothing short of heresy for which if this was an Islamic theocrasy–he would be beheaded for as insult to God.
    It is far more reasonable to say that this man is" mentally ill" or has a physical brain disturbance resulting from deviant eletro-biochemistry which is the probable cause of his criminally deviant behavior

    Reply
  2. Pingback: Key Evidence Barred in Renato Seabra Murder Trial | gaycitynews.com

  3. Pingback: DA Says Rage Over Lost Perks Fueled Portuguese Activist’s Grisly NY Slay | gaycitynews.com

  4. Pingback: Detective Pressed Hard on Renato Seabra’s Statement in Carlos Castro Killing | gaycitynews.com

  5. Faith quotes April 13, 2013 at 7:19 am

    This is better post then your previous one. I came here from twitter sharing well i am your blog follower on twitter, This is amazing blog just want to tell you please continue your sharing with us. In this post i just want to say that #4 point is more powerfull then others. Thank

    Reply
  6. musafir12 April 20, 2013 at 2:51 am

    Pretty good post. I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!
    best quotes

    Reply
  7. smith73 April 26, 2013 at 10:11 am

    this is a very disturbing issue… committing morbid crime now a days and getting away from the law by just pleading or claiming insanity.

    Reply
    • Stuart Baanstra May 19, 2013 at 12:53 am

      Smith, the most "morbid crime" of all is most people being straight. It has its origins in the bible and is the true "insanity".

      Reply
    • Stuart Baanstra May 19, 2013 at 1:20 am

      Most "disturbing" of all is the oppression of homosexuality, over thousands of years, is the spiritual equivalent of Seabra "removing Castro's testicles".

      Reply
  8. go here May 9, 2013 at 8:17 am

    I think the convict is either lying or he is totally insane. If he can prove that he is insane, he may escape the capital punishment. On the other hand, if god indeed told him, it might not be god at all, but satan.

    Reply
    • Stuart Baanstra May 19, 2013 at 12:32 am

      Nice to see the lower-case spelling, but it's neither "god" or "satan", but man. The bible says we're an abomination and it's reasonable to say Castro acted on that belief, hence the heinousness of the crime.

      Reply
  9. Stuart Baanstra May 9, 2013 at 6:22 pm

    Well, here goes. Seems it's boiled down to prooving insanity, though is it [insanity]? Check out any of the legislation in the countries where queer marriage is legal and you'll find exemptions in anti-discrimination law allowing religious groups to say we're an abomination and should be put to death, all with queer lobbyists giving their blessing.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


− three = zero

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>